Articles

Q&A: Why Insurers Lose Customers at Renewal, and How AI Agents Win Them Back

Interview with Xebia's Rahul Jain on why renewals are lost weeks before the expiration date, and what changes when AI agents work the renewal book.

Updated November 19, 2026
7 minutes
‌
Insurance leader in a light blue shirt talks with a colleague in a glass meeting room, a dashboard on the screen ahead

Insurers lose customers at renewal because the decision to leave is made weeks before the expiration date, usually after a slow claim, a failed payment or a price increase that nobody explained. Rahul Jain explains how Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention puts those renewals in front of agents first, reaches customers before they shop, and renews the simple policies straight through, with every exception kept with a person.

Matt Gosselin, who leads marketing for Xebia in the Americas, sat down with Rahul Jain to talk about why insurers and their agencies keep losing customers they could have kept, and how Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention changes the work at the renewal desk. Rahul is Global Business Head for BFSI and Professional Services at Xebia, with more than 25 years helping banks and insurers grow with technology. For the full argument, read Abhishek Dwivedi's article on stopping policy lapses.

Where renewals are lost

Rahul, retention seems to keep slipping across the industry. What's actually going on?

Rahul: Shopping has become the default. LexisNexis Risk Solutions reports that average US auto retention has dropped 5 points since 2021, to 78%, and its 2026 report found that 47% of personal auto policies were shopped at least once in the 12 months to Q4 2025. That's a record. So the renewal isn't a formality anymore. It's a decision the customer makes every year, and most insurers aren't in the room when they make it.

When does that decision actually get made?

Rahul: Earlier than people think, and rarely on renewal day. It's usually a moment: a claim that took too long, a payment that failed and nobody followed up, a premium increase that arrived with no explanation. Accenture's 2022 survey found that 30% of dissatisfied claimants had switched insurers in the past two years, and another 47% were considering it. The signal was there in the insurer's own claims and billing data. It just never reached the agent working the renewal.

Why doesn't it reach them?

Rahul: Because most renewal work still runs from a list. Someone exports the renewals due in the next 30 days, and agents work it top to bottom. Every renewal gets the same effort, so the 50 customers who are about to leave wait behind the 50 who would have renewed anyway. And price becomes the only conversation, because nobody had time to look at cover.

What changes with Agentic Renewal & Retention

What does Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention do differently?

Rahul: Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention changes the order of the work. Six AI agents sit on top of the policy admin, rating, billing and CRM systems an insurer already runs. They rank every renewal by lapse risk, build one view of the customer, reach out before the policy ends, recommend cover that fits, build the quote, and issue the clean renewals straight through. By the time the agent logs in, the riskiest renewals are at the top, with the reason next to each one.

What does "agentic" mean here, in practical terms?

Rahul: It means the agents act, not just report. A dashboard tells you a renewal is overdue. An agent in Agentic Renewal & Retention contacts the consenting customer with a one-click renewal link, follows up within the contact caps you've set, and, if the renewal meets every rule, issues it. Each agent has one job, works on your data, and records why it acted.

How is that different from a CRM reminder?

Rahul: A reminder tells someone a date. Agentic Renewal & Retention tells them which customer is likely to leave and why, and in many cases it has already done the work: the customer view is assembled, the plans are recommended, the quote is ready. That's what moves agent productivity. McKinsey's research reports 10 to 20% higher insurance agent productivity from domain-level AI transformations, and in my view most of that comes from agents spending their time on the right customers.

Where does the claims side come in?

Rahul: It's the same customer, so it's the same problem. Agentic Renewal & Retention includes a claims and servicing assistant: an agent or the insured files the claim in a guided chat, missing documents are flagged before it's submitted, and the customer gets updates until it's paid. A claim handled well is the best retention tool an insurer has. A claim handled badly is the reason the renewal gets shopped.

Who stays in control

Insurers will hear "renews automatically" and get nervous. What does the system decide on its own?

Rahul: Only what the insurer has told it to. Agentic Renewal & Retention issues a renewal straight through when it meets every rule and authority limit your organization sets, and nothing else. Every automated step can be set to require a person's review, and your organization decides which. Agents can override any recommendation with a reason, a senior agent or underwriter decides every referral, and fraud flags never cause an automatic rejection.

And for the compliance team?

Rahul: Governance is built in, but it isn't one-size-fits-all. We configure it to each insurer's policies. Consent is checked before any contact, personal data is masked before any LLM call, and every action has a reason code and an audit trail. The controls support the insurer's compliance program. They don't replace it.

Does an insurer have to replace its core systems to use it?

Rahul: No. Agentic Renewal & Retention works on top of the systems you run today, through API connectors: policy admin such as Guidewire or Duck Creek, rating, billing, CRM. Pricing, rules and the policy stay in your core. It's built on OutSystems and portable to AWS and Google Cloud.

Getting started

What should an insurer expect, and how do they start?

Rahul: Start with their own renewals. Agentic Renewal & Retention is built for personal-lines insurers and the agents, brokers and MGAs who sell for them, and it's configured to each insurer's rules, authority limits and contact caps. Results depend on the book and the process, so we don't promise a retention number up front. We show Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention on the insurer's own scenarios, including a lapsed renewal and an exception that goes to a person, and then measure the results against their baseline. That's a much better conversation than a benchmark from someone else's book.

Last question. What would you tell a head of distribution who thinks their renewal process is fine?

Rahul: Look at last year's lapses and ask when each one was decided. If the answer is "weeks before we called", the process isn't fine. It's just late. The insurers that keep more customers won't be the ones with the biggest teams. They'll be the ones whose agents start every day with the right renewals in front of them.

Want to see Xebia Agentic Renewal & Retention work your own renewal book? Book a demo. For the full picture, read Abhishek Dwivedi's article, How Can Insurers Stop Policy Lapses Before Customers Start Shopping?, and see our view of the insurance industry.

Sources

Written by

Contact

Let’s discuss how we can support your journey.

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌